Skip to main content

Gone but Still Billing: Finding the Subscriptions Offboarding Misses

November 19, 2026

By Rajith Shaji

When someone leaves a company, IT shuts off their email on day one. The subscriptions they signed up for keep billing.

I spend much of my time studying how businesses spend money, and this pattern no longer surprises me. A controller pulls a card statement to close the quarter and finds three charges from a former employee. There's a design tool at $29 a month, a transcription app at $20, and a ChatGPT seat. Nobody approved them as a set, and nobody cancelled them when she left last spring.

These charges are small and recurring, and nobody ever attached them to a vendor record or a contract. This combination makes them very easy to live with. In most organizations I speak with, a meaningful slice of software spend belongs to people who have left. The only way to find it is to go looking.

I see this as a design gap in offboarding rather than carelessness by any one team. It also deserves more attention in Connecticut than many people expect, because of how the state's economy is built.

Why Connecticut's Small Firms Are Especially Exposed

Connecticut runs on small firms, according to the SBA Office of Advocacy's 2025 state profile. The state has 381,129 small businesses, which make up 99.4% of all businesses and employ 48.1% of its workforce. Most of these firms have no procurement team, and many have no full-time IT person either. Many do have a trusted CPA, who is often the first to notice when something in the books looks off.

These same firms now buy software the way large companies do, one card swipe at a time. Zylo's 2026 SaaS Management Index found that business units control 81% of SaaS spend, while IT directly manages just 15%. It also found that expense-based SaaS spend rose 267% in a single year. ChatGPT is now the most expensed application in Zylo's data. Zylo studies larger organizations, but I believe the pattern is even stronger in a 30-person firm. In a firm that size, there was never an IT gatekeeper to go around in the first place.

Why Offboarding Checklists Miss Card-Bought Subscriptions

A typical offboarding checklist covers the laptop, the building badge, the email account, final pay, and benefits. Each item is on the list because it lives in a system that someone owns. HR keeps the personnel file, IT manages the user directory, and operations tracks the hardware.

A subscription bought on a company card by one person sits outside all of those systems. HR never knew it existed, and IT never set it up, so IT has nothing to switch off. Finance sees the charge, but only as a familiar line on a monthly statement. Over time, this familiarity makes the charge almost invisible.

This behavior is widespread, as 1Password reports that 52% of employees admit to downloading work apps without IT's approval. Meanwhile, most companies still handle the exit process by hand. The 2026 BetterCloud State of SaaS report found that only about one in four organizations automate offboarding.

The checklist does its job well, but it never asks one important question. I'll come back to that question after looking at where to find these charges.

How to Spot Orphaned Subscriptions in Card and Reimbursement Data

The encouraging news is that the evidence already sits in data the finance team controls. You don't need specialist software to begin this work. You need a year of card transactions, a year of expense claims, and a list of recent leavers.

Start by pulling out every recurring charge with the same merchant, a similar amount, and a regular rhythm. Then link each charge to a cardholder or claimant and compare it against the leaver list. Any charge still billing after someone's last day belongs on the shortlist.

A few patterns deserve a second look. Annual renewals are the easiest to miss, because they appear once and then vanish for eleven months. Sometimes a charge moves from one person's expense claims to a colleague's company card. This usually means the colleague inherited the tool without inheriting the decision behind it. Duplicates tell their own story as well. When four people pay one vendor on separate plans, there's often a team plan nobody set up.

Reimbursements need extra care, especially when an employee paid on a personal card and claimed the cost each month. Once that person leaves, the claims stop, but the subscription may keep running with company files inside it. This account never appears as an ongoing charge in the books. The only clue is a reimbursement history that stops abruptly.

Once you have the shortlist, ask one question about every line: who uses this today? If nobody can tell you within a week, you usually have your answer.

The Contract and Data Risks That Outlast the Employee

The monthly cost is what people notice first, but in my view it's the smaller concern.

Most of these tools were bought with a single click on "I agree." Many of those terms renew automatically, often once a year. The person who clicked has left, but the business remains the customer. Any renewal reminder also goes to the email address used at sign-up, which IT closed on day one.

Connecticut lawmakers clearly understand how auto-renewals catch people out. The state's updated auto-renewal law took effect on July 1, 2026. It requires covered businesses to send annual renewal reminders that show the cost, the frequency, and how to cancel. The law protects consumers rather than business buyers, but the lesson still applies. A reminder only works if somebody reads it.

The data inside these tools is the bigger worry. An orphaned subscription may hold client files, call recordings, a customer list, or months of AI prompts. Some of those prompts will almost certainly contain client names and figures. If the account uses a personal login, the company may be unable to export or delete anything.

Former staff do sometimes go back into these accounts after they leave. 1Password found that 38% of employees have accessed a former employer's accounts after leaving. BetterCloud found that 18% of enterprises had a breach in the past year through a former user who kept access.

Connecticut law attaches real obligations to these risks. Under the state's breach notification law, affected residents must be notified within 60 days of discovery. The Attorney General must receive notice no later than the residents do. Where Social Security or taxpayer identification numbers are involved, residents must be offered 24 months of credit monitoring.

CPA firms face an even higher bar. The FTC Safeguards Rule treats tax preparers as financial institutions and expects strong access controls. Those controls belong in a written information security plan, and IRS Publication 4557 explains how to build one. A tool holding client tax data with no current administrator is hard to square with these rules.

Five Fixes to Recommend to Clients, No Procurement Team Required

When I raise this with finance leaders at smaller firms, their first reaction is easy to understand. They don't want to hire a procurement team over a few software subscriptions. They shouldn't have to, because a handful of low-cost habits can close most of the gap.

  1. Add one question to every exit. Ask which tools the person pays for or manages that the company might not know about. Put the question to the departing employee and their manager before the last day. People share this information freely on their way out, but they are much harder to reach later.
  2. Give every recurring charge a named owner. A shared spreadsheet is enough to start. When an owner leaves, each line moves to someone else or gets cancelled during the handover.
  3. Insist on a company email for every business sign-up. This simple rule keeps the account, the data, and the renewal notices inside the business. It works no matter who joins or leaves.
  4. Run a quarterly sweep. Check recurring card and expense charges against the current staff list every three months. The first pass takes real effort, but later sweeps take about an afternoon.
  5. Export, then cancel. When a tool has no owner and little clear value, save its contents and cancel it. If someone needs it, you'll hear about it within days. In my experience, the request rarely comes.

None of these steps needs new software, only someone who accepts that looking is part of their job.

In Closing

I now see orphaned subscriptions as a symptom of a wider gap between teams. HR, IT, and finance each do their own work well, yet nobody owns the space in between. Accountants are well placed to close that gap, because the trail runs straight through the ledger.

The most useful question a CPA can ask a client this year is a simple one. Ask what the business still pays for that nobody remembers signing up for.

Rajith Shaji is the co-founder and CEO of Volopay, a global financial technology company building the financial operating system for modern businesses. Volopay helps businesses manage corporate spending, payments, expenses, accounts payable, accounts receivable, and other financial operations through a unified platform.